Two Squabbling Reporters
There’s a fair bit of squabbling going on over Frank Rose’s recent article for Wired Magazine, How Madison Avenue Is Wasting Millions on a Deserted Second Life
. New World Notes editor-reporter Hamlet Au took a few jabs at the Wired piece, and Frank Rose fired back in a comment.
Au tips his hat to Rose’s chutzpah in trying to remove the wool from the corporate eye, but asserts that the article is riddled with the popular media myths and untruths about Second Life. Au suggests that Rose is too inexperienced with SL to know truth from fiction—that he just doesn’t get it. It seems that Frank Rose is just one more of those silly, misinformed media reporters who couldn’t tell an avatar from his own ass.
In response, Rose takes a scapel to Au’s article, systematically cutting off its supporting evidence and leaving it castrated. Rose points out that the New World Notes piece itself suffers from the hype, half-truths, and blindness that Au accuses Rose’s article of possessing. Perhaps Hamlet Au is not as infallible as he likes to believe.
Here we have two reporters, swatting and spitting at each other. Which of them is right?


So I was reading 
Recent Comments